Understanding gender diversity is crucial in today’s modern world. A notable example is the global controversy surrounding the 2024 Olympic women’s boxing competition, where it was discovered that a female athlete with male XY chromosomes could compete against women with XX chromosomes. This sparked widespread criticism and debate worldwide.

This article aims to clarify what gender diversity (Intersex) is, why some women have XY chromosomes, and whether they truly possess a strength advantage over women with XX chromosomes.

Intersex: Why Do Some Women Have Male XY Chromosomes?

What is Intersex? Understanding Gender Diversity

Intersex, or gender diversity, refers to a group of conditions where a person is born with sexual characteristics or reproductive organs that do not fit the typical definitions of male or female. This may involve chromosomes, gonads, sex hormones, or atypical development of genitalia.

Credit: http://www.mayaposch.com/intersex.php 

Women with XY Chromosomes

One well-known condition within the Intersex spectrum is women with XY chromosomes, commonly found in individuals with Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS). Women with AIS have a male (XY) chromosome pattern but, due to the body’s inability to respond to androgen hormones, develop external female genitalia. Typically, individuals with AIS are raised as females and are often identified as female.

AIS is part of a broader category known as Differences in Sexual Development (DSD), which refers to congenital variations in physical sex characteristics. These variations can arise from differences in chromosomes, hormones, or the physical structure of the sex organs. DSD can result in a person having sex characteristics that do not match the sex assigned at birth.

Scientifically, sex is typically determined by the presence or absence of the Y chromosome. Generally, females have XX chromosomes, and males have XY chromosomes. However, a common scenario is when individuals with XY chromosomes develop as females, a condition known as Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS).

Types of Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS)
AIS is categorized into two main types:

1. Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (CAIS): Individuals with CAIS have fully female external genitalia and are usually assigned female at birth.
2. Partial Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (PAIS): Individuals with PAIS may have external genitalia that appear male, female, or a combination of both, depending on the level of androgen response.

How Do Women with XY Chromosomes Differ from Transgender Individuals?

There is a clear distinction between DSD (Differences in Sexual Development) and being transgender. DSD refers to physical and biological variations present from birth, involving chromosomes, hormones, or sex organ structures that differ from typical male or female characteristics. Examples of DSD include Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS) and Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH), where individuals may have ambiguous sex characteristics or characteristics that do not align with the sex assigned at birth.

In contrast, being transgender refers to having a gender identity that does not align with the sex assigned at birth. Transgender individuals may express their gender differently from their assigned sex and may or may not choose to undergo gender transition. Being transgender is related to a person’s internal sense of identity rather than physical or biological characteristics present from birth.

Therefore, DSD and being transgender have different meanings. DSD is about physical and biological characteristics present from birth, while being transgender concerns an internal gender identity that differs from the sex assigned at birth. Understanding this distinction is essential for recognizing and respecting gender diversity and individual identity.

Credit: https://www.dw.com/en/fact-check-do-trans-athletes-have-an-advantage-in-elite-sport/a-58583988 

Characteristics of Women with XY Chromosomes

Women with XY chromosomes and CAIS typically have external appearances and sexual development similar to typical females, but they lack a uterus and fallopian tubes and do not menstruate. However, these individuals may still have children through alternative medical procedures, such as:

Egg Donation
Egg donation is an alternative medical option for women with XY chromosomes who cannot produce eggs. This process involves using eggs from a donor, which are fertilized to create embryos. The donor eggs are selected from healthy individuals who meet specific criteria, allowing women with XY chromosomes the opportunity to have a child genetically related to their partner.

Artificial Insemination
Artificial insemination is a medical procedure where sperm is directly inserted into a woman’s reproductive system without sexual intercourse. This method helps couples facing infertility issues and can be done by injecting sperm into the uterus (IUI - Intrauterine Insemination) or the cervix (ICI - Intracervical Insemination). Women without a uterus or with XY chromosomes can use this method by combining the sperm with a donor egg and transferring the embryo to a surrogate mother.

In Vitro Fertilization (IVF)
IVF involves fertilizing donor eggs with sperm in a laboratory to create embryos. These embryos are then transferred to the uterus of a surrogate mother. IVF is an effective method for women with XY chromosomes to have children, even if they lack a uterus or fallopian tubes.

Surrogacy
Surrogacy is when another woman carries and delivers a baby for a woman with XY chromosomes who cannot conceive. The embryo, created through artificial insemination or IVF, is transferred to the surrogate’s uterus. Surrogacy provides an opportunity for women who cannot conceive to become mothers.

Credit: https://omegagoldenfertility.com/are-children-conceived-from-donor-egg-ivf-your-biological-children/ 

Diagnosis and Treatment of Intersex in Women with XY Chromosomes

AIS is often diagnosed when a child does not menstruate upon reaching puberty or when abnormalities in genitalia are detected at birth. Diagnosis involves blood tests to measure hormone levels, chromosome testing, and medical examinations.

Treatment for AIS depends on the individual’s characteristics and needs. Counseling to understand and accept one’s gender is crucial for those with AIS. Surgical interventions or hormone therapy may also be considered to align with the identified gender later in life.

Social Understanding and Acceptance

Women with XY chromosomes often face physical and psychological challenges. Support from family, medical professionals, and society is vital for building confidence and self-understanding, helping those with AIS lead fulfilling and happy lives.

Credit: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/who-is-olympian-imane-khelif-an-algerian-woman-boxer-is-facing-anti-trans-backlash 

The 2024 Paris Olympic Women’s Boxing Controversy: A Case of a Female Boxer with XY Chromosomes

There has been widespread debate regarding the participation of athletes with differences in sex development in women’s sports, particularly in the 2024 Olympic Games. The regulations and guidelines set by the International Olympic Committee (IOC) are designed to ensure fairness in competition, which may include specific requirements concerning the levels of testosterone, a male sex hormone, in athletes competing in the female category.

Some believe that athletes with higher testosterone levels may have a competitive advantage, while others argue that imposing hormone restrictions infringes on the rights of certain athletes.

Meanwhile, decisions and changes in regulations have a significant impact on athletes with hormonal disorders, such as those who must adjust their hormone levels to comply with competition rules, which could affect their health and physical performance.